Monster Mac and Cheese

Monster Mac and Cheese was born in a tiny Austin apartment when a last-minute Halloween party needed a savory showstopper. Monster Mac and Cheese got its glow from spinach “slime” and silly mozzarella eyes that cracked everyone up before the first bite. Monster Mac and Cheese tastes like ultra-creamy stovetop comfort with a ghoulish twist that kids and grown-ups devour. Monster Mac and Cheese comes together fast—blend the greens, whisk the cheese sauce, twirl in pasta, then top with olive-studded “eyeballs.” Monster Mac and Cheese proves spooky food can be bold, cozy, and totally party-ready.

Why You’ll Love This Monster Mac and Cheese

Monster Mac and Cheese turns classic, ultra-creamy stovetop comfort into a green, party-ready centerpiece with spinach “slime” and goofy olive-studded cheese eyes that bring instant smiles without complicated steps or special gear. The sauce clings to elbows beautifully, while the green blend stays mild and kid-approved, so flavor hits cheesy-first with a fun Halloween twist for all ages. Make it boxed or from-scratch, and scale for potlucks—fast assembly, easy garnishes, and reliable creaminess keep stress low and servings steady.

Ingredients for Monster Mac and Cheese

• 12 oz elbow macaroni
• 2 cups whole milk, plus more to loosen
• 3 cups shredded sharp cheddar (or cheddar-jack blend)
• 2 tbsp unsalted butter
• 2 tbsp flour (for quick thickening)
• 1/2 tsp mustard powder, 1/4 tsp garlic powder
• 1/2–3/4 tsp kosher salt, 1/4 tsp black pepper
• 4 cups baby spinach, steamed and blended with 2–4 tbsp water (green “slime”)
• 8–12 mozzarella string cheese rounds (cut into coins)
• 8–12 black or green olive slices for “pupils”
  Optional: 1/2 cup Havarti or Monterey Jack for extra melt; pinch smoked paprika; 1–2 tbsp cream cheese for silkiness

Ingredient	Purpose
Cheddar + milk	Creamy, tangy base sauce
Flour + butter	Quick thickening (roux)
Spinach puree	“Monster” green color, mild flavor
String cheese + olives	Edible eyeballs on top

Substitutions & Variations for Monster Mac and Cheese

• Boxed shortcut: Prepare boxed mac per package, then blend in spinach slime and add eyeballs for the quickest route to green, cheesy goodness.
• Pesto twist: Swap spinach puree for broccoli–spinach pesto to add herbaceous depth and a vibrant, clingy sauce that still reads bright green.
• Gluten-free: Use GF elbows and a cornstarch slurry instead of flour for thickening; simmer to glossy and smooth before adding cheese.
• Extra spooky: Color-crunch with crushed green tortilla chips or panko on top, or serve in individual “monster cups” for party-friendly portions.

Step-by-Step Instructions for Monster Mac and Cheese

• Boil elbows in salted water to al dente; reserve 1 cup pasta water, then drain so the sauce can be adjusted silky without clumping or dryness.
• Make green “slime”: Steam spinach until wilted, then blend with 2–4 tbsp water to a smooth, bright puree that folds cleanly into cheese sauce without fibrous bits.
• Build the roux: Melt butter in a pot over medium; whisk in flour 1 minute until foamy to cook off raw taste and prepare the base for a glossy sauce.
• Add milk slowly, whisking until smooth; simmer 2–3 minutes to thicken slightly, then season with salt, pepper, mustard powder, and garlic powder for savory backbone.
• Off heat, stir in shredded cheddar (and Havarti or cream cheese if using) by handfuls until fully melted, then whisk in spinach puree for a bold, even green.
• Toss in pasta; splash in reserved pasta water as needed so sauce stays fluid and coats elbows evenly, then taste and adjust seasoning before topping.

Pro Tips for Success with Monster Mac and Cheese

• Shred cheese from a block; anti-caking on pre-shredded can make sauce gritty, while fresh shreds melt velvety and bind with the spinach puree better.
• Keep heat moderate; if cheese breaks or turns grainy, whisk in a spoon of cream cheese or a splash of milk to re-emulsify and smooth texture fast.
• For neon green, blend spinach extra fine and add a spoon of pesto or broccoli puree for brightness without overpowering the classic mac flavor profile.
• Season last; spinach and cheddar can shift salt levels, so finish with a final pinch after combining to keep flavors punchy but balanced for all ages.
• Make eyeballs just before serving; coin slices of string cheese topped with olive rounds hold shape and contrast best on hot, glossy mac right off the stove.

Storage & Reheating Tips for Monster Mac and Cheese

• Refrigerate mac in an airtight container 3–4 days; store eyeball toppings separately to maintain clean edges and prevent brine from bleeding color.
• Reheat gently with a splash of milk on the stovetop, stirring to revive creaminess; add a little extra shredded cheddar to restore body and sheen if needed.
• Freeze up to 2 months without eyeballs; thaw overnight, reheat with milk, then garnish with fresh cheese coins and olives for crisp, defined monster eyes.

What to Serve With Monster Mac and Cheese

• Pair Monster Mac and Cheese with roasted broccoli or green beans for color and crunch; a quick sheet-pan roast balances the creamy sauce and keeps the Halloween spread fresh and lively.
• Add garlic bread or soft dinner rolls for scooping every last bit of cheesy “slime,” turning the bowl into a cozy, crowd-pleasing main at parties.
• Offer a crisp salad with lemony vinaigrette—peppery arugula or mixed greens cut the richness and frame the bright-green mac as the star.
• Serve party-style alongside monster cups, spooky nuggets, or mac-stuffed peppers for a themed table with easy grab-and-go bites for kids and adults.

FAQs for Monster Mac and Cheese

• How do I make the sauce super smooth? Build a proper roux, add milk gradually, melt freshly shredded cheese off heat, and blend spinach to a fine puree before stirring in for silkiness.
• Can I use boxed mac? Yes—prepare per package, then fold in spinach puree and add cheese-olive eyeballs for an ultra-fast, party-ready version with great color and flavor.
• What cheeses melt best? Sharp cheddar for flavor, plus Havarti or Monterey Jack for stretch; avoid only pre-shredded blends to prevent grit from anti-caking agents.
• How do I keep it bright green? Blend spinach very smooth and mix it in off heat; add a spoon of pesto or broccoli puree to boost hue without overpowering taste.
• Can I make it gluten-free? Use GF elbows and thicken with cornstarch or a slurry instead of flour; simmer to glossy before adding cheese for a stable, creamy finish.

Nutrition Information (per serving)

• Approximate per serving (1/6 recipe): 520–700 calories, 22–30g protein, 22–34g fat, 55–75g carbs, depending on milk type, cheese mix, and add-ins like cream cheese.
• Lighten it with part-skim milk and reduced cheddar; enrich gently with a spoon of cream cheese for silk without heaviness if texture needs help after reheating.
• Sodium varies by cheese and olives; rinse olives and season at the end to keep salt balanced while preserving bold, cheesy satisfaction for all ages.

Print